search instagram twitter facebook pinterest chevron-right chevron-left email menu cross
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to menu-404 navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Let's Eat Cake

Let's Eat Cake is the lifestyle site for Millennial women. We’re your source for lifestyle, entertainment, fashion, beauty, jokes, puns, food news, coffee trends, and baking recipes.

  • Lifestyle
  • Food + Drink
  • Funny
  • Recipes
  • Entertainment
  • Beauty
  • News
  • Sex + Relationships
  • Contact
  • About
  • Subscribe
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • Advertise
© 2023 Let's Eat Cake
  • Food + Drink
  • Funny
  • Lifestyle
  • Recipes
Home » Lifestyle » Entertainment

15 of Our Favorite Scary TV Shows That Need a Rewatch This Halloween

By Jacqueline Gualtieri | September 28, 2022 | Updated on September 30, 2022 | Leave a Comment
This post may contain affiliate links that we collect a share of sales from. Click here for more details.
Scary TV Shows - Supernatural
Scary TV Shows - Midnight Mass
Scary TV Shows - The Haunting of Hill House
Scary TV Shows - Lovecraft Country
Scary TV Shows - Courage the Cowardly Dog
Scary TV Shows - Are You Afraid of the Dark?
Scary TV Shows - Over the Garden Wall
Scary TV Shows - Bates Motel
Scary TV Shows - Chucky
Scary TV Shows - Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
Scary TV Shows - You
Scary TV Shows - The Sandman
Scary TV Shows - The Twilight Zone
Scary TV Shows - Stranger Things
Scary TV Shows - American Horror Story
Scary TV Shows

‘Tis the season to be jolly…wait, no. We’re getting ahead of ourselves. ‘Tis the season to be spooky! And there’s no better way to celebrate this creeptastic time of year than with a marathon of scary TV shows.

Although, consuming copious amounts of pumpkin pastries is pretty great, too.

Even though scary movies may seem to dominate the entertainment world around Halloween, you can’t ignore the brilliance of a spooky series. With multiple episodes, and often multiple seasons, a chilling show can pull you even deeper into a dark world.

And subsequently, even more terrifying nightmares. Hello insomnia!

But if you’re the type of person who thrives on terror, then you’ll want to make sure all of these shows are on your list to watch. So grab your pumpkin-spiced popcorn (you know they make it!) and strap in for some of the best scary tales out there.

 

15 of Our Favorite Scary TV Shows

1. “Supernatural”

It ran for 15 seasons, but the best thrills can be found in the early years. Originally running in a monster-of-the-week format, you’ll discover terrors in this show you didn’t even know existed. Think you’re scared of werewolves? Wait until you meet a rougarou.

However, we stand by the Bloody Mary episode as being the creepiest. Get ready to never look in a mirror again! Oh, and you know how you’re scared of clowns? Meet teleporting killer clowns. We’ll pass on the circus this year, thanks.

Scary TV Shows - Supernatural
Photo Credit: The CW

 

2. “American Horror Story”

Once again, we’re suggesting that you stick with the early years for this scary TV show. Tate Langdon may be hot, but he’s also absolutely terrifying.

From Lady Gaga engaging in a blood orgy to a demon baby surviving off possums in a basement, there’s not a lot “American Horror Story” hasn’t done. If you were looking for a new phobia, they’re happy to give you one! Even though all we asked for was socks this year.

Scary TV Shows - American Horror Story
Photo Credit: FX

 

3. “Stranger Things”

Now for this show, the creepier moments of “Stranger Things” come in later seasons. Though it’s a sci-fi series, Season 4 goes full on horror.

One, two, Freddy’s coming for you. Sorry, we mean Vecna. It’s clear that ‘80s horror inspired the most recent season of this Netflix hit. And we’re not just talking about Will’s haircut.

Scary TV Shows - Stranger Things
Photo Credit: Netflix

 

4. “The Twilight Zone”

This classic series has a habit of getting under your skin – you’ll start to question everything you know when you binge-watch these episodes. Who’s to say that the man serving you a drink isn’t from Venus? Or that aliens aren’t pulling strings during your fight with the neighbors?

“The Twilight Zone” is the OG of creepiness. And although it relied heavily on aliens, the show taught generations the meaning of terror in many forms. But did we mention the aliens?

Scary TV Shows - The Twilight Zone
Photo Credit: CBS Television Studios

 

5. “The Sandman”

Oh, Mr. Sandman, bring us a dream. Because Netflix’s “The Sandman” is mostly delivering nightmares. Although this series, based on the Neil Gaiman comics of the same name, isn’t a horror show, we still find ourselves with goosebumps.

It’s not that there’s jump scares galore. It’s more about the fact that everything feels very real. Walking into a diner at the wrong time can get you killed in this world. You wanted a waffle, and bam! You’re dead. And covered in syrup. Artificial syrup at that!

Scary TV Shows - The Sandman
Photo Credit: Netflix

 

6. “You”

Most scary TV shows lean into supernatural scares, but this Netflix series gives us the ultimate terror: a man with a penchant for murder who thinks he’s the hero.

“You” twists the concept of a white knight on its head (and then rips the head off). And “you” as a person will spend the series wondering how someone as attractive as Penn Badgley could freak you out entirely. And make you question if you’re really ready to start dating again.

Scary TV Shows - You
Photo Credit: Netflix

 

7. “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina”

Remember “Sabrina the Teenage Witch” and that time she got addicted to pancakes? So silly, right? Yeah, that’s not Netflix’s “Chilling Adventures of Sabrina.”

The second Sabrina Spellman series is filled with gore, death, and the King of Hell. She sure has come a long way from her basic cable days, but as they say: with better outfits and cuter haircuts comes blood and demonic possessions. We’re pretty sure we heard that somewhere.

Scary TV Shows - Chilling Adventures of Sabrina
Photo Credit: Netflix

 

8. “Chucky”

In one heck of a sequel, our favorite murderous doll has returned in a series on Syfy. And he’s brought along many of his former friends. He did promise to be friends until the very end, after all.

But don’t get too attached to anyone on this show because Chucky’s out for blood. Oh, and some casual world domination. Don’t children’s toys have normal hobbies anymore?

Scary TV Shows - Chucky
Photo Credit: David Kirschner Productions

 

9. “Bates Motel”

So far, we’ve talked about a reboot and a sequel, so let’s add a prequel to the list! “Psycho” redefined terror in cinema, and “Bates Motel” brought that terror to the small screen.

This series gives us a look at the relationship between Norman Bates and his mother. You know, before the whole stabbing Janet Leigh in the shower thing. Things go from zero to Oedipus real quick, and just when you think you’ve seen it all, there’s…Rihanna? Oh….so this is the monster under her bed!

Scary TV Shows - Bates Motel
Photo Credit: Universal Television

 

10. “Over the Garden Wall”

Who knew an animated series could you give you the willies so well? Half heartfelt, half bone-chilling, “Over the Garden Wall” makes you question the meaning of mortality and family. All while you’re trying to decide where to go fo dinner – life is exhausting!

Everything isn’t as it seems in this series, and even the ending is up to interpretation. So, you’ll either end this show on a happy note or with a wave of anxiety. Good luck!

Scary TV Shows - Over the Garden Wall
Photo Credit: Cartoon Network

 

11. “Are You Afraid of the Dark?”

Wanna relive your childhood? Skip the Saturday morning cartoons and try this classic Nickelodeon series. Sure, you can still watch it with a bowl of cereal.

Gather ‘round the Midnight Society, and listen to stories that you had no business hearing when you were little. Like, there’s an episode where young girls are literally turned into dolls. And another with a clown that could give Pennywise a run for his money. Who let us watch this?

Scary TV Shows - Are You Afraid of the Dark?
Photo Credit: Nickelodeon

 

12. “Courage the Cowardly Dog”

And here’s one more kids show we had no business watching. “Courage the Cowardly Dog” taught us the meaning of existential crisis years before we had to pay bills. Just whisper the words “King Ramses’ curse” to a millennial and watch their hair stand on end.

“Courage” was often heartfelt, but that didn’t make up for the pure terror it inspired in its young viewers. From mysterious entities behind an emotionless porcelain mask to real-world floating heads juxtaposed against the cartoons, “Courage” truly did not care if kids never slept again. Or, at least in their own beds.

Scary TV Shows - Courage the Cowardly Dog
Photo Credit: Cartoon Network

 

13. “Lovecraft Country”

H.P. Lovecraft was a master of horror, so it’s hard to imagine many things more terrifying than his creations coming to life. But “Lovecraft Country” manages to make many humans out to be far scarier than the mythical monsters.

Unfortunately, this hit series would only be a one-hit-wonder. It only got one season, despite a whopping 18 Emmy nominations. So, consider this our plea to HBO to please bring this series back.

We know it would be epic. And, maybe if they stop making Game of Thrones spinoffs, George R. R. Martin will finally finish The Winds of Winter.

Scary TV Shows - Lovecraft Country
Photo Credit: Warner Bros

 

14. “The Haunting of Hill House”

We bet we only have to say one thing to give you goosebumps. Ready? “Bent-Neck Lady.” Annnnnd there’s that chill.

This cinematically stunning show is also bone chillingly scary. Yes, the jump scares are a lot, but there’s also a large, ominous feeling that seeps throughout the entire show. You never know what will scare you next. Maybe watch this with the lights on. Actually, are lights scary now? We really don’t know.

Scary TV Shows - The Haunting of Hill House
Photo Credit: Netflix

 

15. “Midnight Mass”

What do you do when you see something that is clearly a vampire? Apparently, start a cult! Okay, so maybe the characters in “Midnight Mass” aren’t the smartest. But the showrunners definitely know what their doing.

From the same creator as “The Haunting of Hill House,” the horror series takes a holy twist on the vampire legend. Let’s just say that these aren’t the sparkly vamps of “Twilight.” But they do give Rob Pat a run for his money in the looks department. Sorry, Team Edward.

Scary TV Shows - Midnight Mass
Photo Credit: Netflix
  • Author
  • Recent Posts
Jacqueline Gualtieri
Jacqueline Gualtieri
Jacqueline Gualtieri is a writer and editor who loves all things pop culture. As an entertainment journalist, SEO specialist, and film and TV enthusiast, Jacqueline enjoys combining her love of writing with her love of Netflix and Disney. She currently covers pop culture trends, food news, and product roundups for Let's Eat Cake. Her work can also be found in HuffPost, Spoon University, and Insider. 

She's also a published short story author who has appeared in anthologies like A Murder of Storytellers and the Abstract Elephant. Jacqueline challenges herself to learn one new skill per year, so you can often find her struggling to master crocheting, knitting, and embroidery when she's not writing. 

Connect with her on her website or LinkedIn.
Jacqueline Gualtieri
Latest posts by Jacqueline Gualtieri (see all)
  • 21 Easter Desserts That’ll Go Over Better Than Bringing a Bunch of Chocolate Bunnies to Brunch - March 28, 2023
  • 20 Spring Cocktails That Feel Like Sunshine In A (Whiskey) Glass - March 28, 2023
  • I Tried the New Liquid Death Iced Teas and Was Surprised - March 14, 2023
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. This post may contain affiliate links from Amazon and other sites that we collect a share of sales from.

Read This Next

The 16 Scariest Alien Movies To Watch After Jordan Peele’s “Nope”

The 16 Scariest Alien Movies To Watch After Jordan Peele’s “Nope”

The 13 Best Scary Books to Get in the Spooky Spirit 

The 13 Best Scary Books to Get in the Spooky Spirit 

Scare Yourself Silly with the 19 Best Horror Movies of 2021

Scare Yourself Silly with the 19 Best Horror Movies of 2021

The 10 Most Underrated and Overrated Halloween Movies

The 10 Most Underrated and Overrated Halloween Movies

Reader Interactions

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published.

Primary Sidebar

Trending Now

  • Adult Jokes 50 Adult Jokes That We Laughed At Because We’re Very Mature
  • Adult Dirty Jokes 65 Dirty Adult Jokes You Should Text Your Partner
  • Starbucks Spring Cups Tumblers 2023 Here’s Your Look at Starbucks’ Spring Cups and Tumblers for 2023

Footer

  • Categories
  • Food + Drink
  • Funny
  • Travel
  • Lifestyle
  • Recipes
  • News
  • About
  • Contact
  • Press
  • Advertise
  • Web Stories
  • Editorial Policy
  • Newsletter
© 2016–2023 Let's Eat Cake
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Service